Thursday, March 21, 2013

Tiferet "Merges" with HALB

The start-up school Tiferet, in the 5 Towns, was supposed to follow the He'atid model of using blended learning to reduce costs and lower tuition.  They just announced that rather than starting a new school they are going to merge with Hebrew Academy of Long Beach and try to incorporate their methods into the existing school (see the announcement, from their website, after the jump).  They haven't yet announced what the tuition will be but if tuition is not significantly reduced people won't consider this a merger but simply Tiferet giving up on its plan to open up an  affordable school.  At the very least, the funds from AJE should help with tuition reduction in the short run.
Tiferet logo.

HALB Integrates Tiferet Academy in Partnership with AJE

The Hebrew Academy of Long Beach (HALB) and Tiferet Academy (Tiferet) have agreed to unify their efforts in 2013, with the support of Affordable Jewish Education Project (AJE). HALB will incorporate Tiferet's blended-learning educational approach and students into their thriving school of 1,700 students to accelerate their respective efforts to provide excellent Jewish education at affordable rates to Five Towns families.

As part of the arrangement, AJE will be funding the implementation of the blended learning program within HALB.

"AJE is very excited for this groundbreaking partnership that will further spread its mission of providing a high-quality, affordable jewish education to every child," said Jeff Kiderman, Executive Director of AJE. "The HALB community is very fortunate to have visionary professional and lay leaders who, together with the incredibly dedicated Tiferet team, are working to establish a new gold standard in day school education."

"We are confident that our partnership with AJE will provide HALB with the resources and innovation to accelerate our delivery of 21st Century educational technologies," said Lance Hirt, President of HALB's board of directors. "We could not be more enthusiastic about the educational opportunities this will create for our children."

"We are thrilled to work together with HALB and the AJE in improving the quality and affordability of Jewish education," said Avi Muchnick, a spokesperson for Tiferet. "The immediate potential to positively impact 1,700 students is tremendous and would have otherwise taken us many years to accomplish independently."

As part of the transition, Tiferet's students will move to the HALB campus where they will become a part of the HALB student body. Tiferet's blended learning program will be rolled out to select elementary school classes within HALB. Rabbi Avrumi Sacks, Head of School at Tiferet, has been appointed to be Chief Academic Officer of AJE. In that capacity, he will join the HALB administration as a representative of AJE, where he will work with HALB Principal Rabbi Plotkin to institute and support the blended-learning education program inside HALB elementary school.

"While we have been aggressively developing an educational model that incorporates leading technologies, we believe that Rabbi Sack's leadership of this effort within our elementary school and early childhood center will turbo charge our efforts," said Rabbi Plotkin. "I am very excited about the many programs we will be launching with the help of the AJE."

"I'm very excited to work with Rabbi Plotkin and the HALB administration in accelerating the educational growth of their students," said Rabbi Sacks. "HALB is renowned for fostering a warm, lifelong connection with its students, and we are looking forward to being a part of that relationship."

The program specifics will be announced to parents later this year.

Comments (50)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
It looks like the house of cards is starting to fall. May be a matter of time but I suspect we will be hearing some big announcements from the others soon.

Those who believe that heatid is too big to fail should know that the conversations have already started and it is not hard to see the writing on the wall about which school they will merge with. Heatid parents should probably make their voices heard soon about which of the legacy schools they want to send their kids to now before the decision is made for them.
Anon, is what you say the function of any actual (and factual) evidence, or simply speculation and rumor-starting? If you have any first hand knowledge then you might want to consider citing it; simply saying :I suspect" or alluding to phantom "conversations" will not persuade anyone and will invite accusations that you are a legacy apologist chumming the waters. As it stands your post seems like just so much bitterness and baseless ranting. If you have something real to share, please share it.
I am a little puzzled how anyone can interpret this as anything but a 'win' for AJE and Tiferet. AJE's goal all along is to make education affordable for everyone. How do you read this letter and see that the 'house of cards is starting to fall'? What was HALB's gain to try and save Tiferet? AJE has plenty of money to start a school and had no need for HALB. Read the letter carefully - it clearly says that a person from AJE will now be an administrator in the school and the school is going to adopt the blended learning model.
If everyone remembers way back to Chump's blog, the founders of He'atid went to at least one existing school, offered to fly their heads down to schools that used this model and wanted this school to integrate blended and differentiated learning into their school to make it more affordable. The school refused and a new school, He'atid was opened. My guess is that there will be a merger in the future in BC. Not becuase He'atid is going to fail - they seem far from doing that as they will outgrow their building after next year (as an example Noam was in that building much longer) but because all along, the goal is to make education affordable to all -merging with an existing school and having that school adopt He'atid's model will only advance that goal.
Buzzkill914's avatar

Buzzkill914 · 627 weeks ago

S.P. What's HALB's tuition going to be next year? Are Tiferet students now paying more? Answer those questions and you'll see why this is as far from a "win" as they come.
Buzzkill914 - I dont know. It seems you do, so please tell me. What will HALB's students be paying next year /What will Tiferet students be paying next year?
Also, while you are at it, if TIferet was not going to start/ was going to fail - what is HALB's interest in getting involved with them? Why even bother? When that Co-op school failed in West Orange two years ago, the kids were absorbed in the other schools with maybe some tuition lowering. That was all. Please explain to me how what is writen in the letter - that HALB will be starting blended learning, will have an admin from AJE - why HALB would do that?
Clealry this is a win for HALB...they are only piloting a program in select elementary school classes according the the article. Yet they are getting all the resources and funding from AJE plus they are getting back the kids that they were going to loose to tiferet.

The article doesn't say they are switching the whole school. It's going to depend on how this "pilot" goes.

Win all around for HALB. They get the money and resources and kids but don't have to commit to anything.
Buster - definitely. By saying it was a win for AJE and Tiferet I didnt' mean to imply that it wasn't a win for HALB as well. AJE and Tiferet did not need HALB and HALB did not need Tiferet. As someone wrote in a previous post - it seems to me that this was a case of people getting togetehr and talking and coming up with a joint venture that hopes to be beneficial for all. To your point about not committing to anything - I am pretty certain HALB has made committments and that if they dont follow thru in terms of what AJE wants this merger to look like, AJE will pull their funding.
HALB hasn't lowered its tuition rate, so it's a big loss for AJE. Credit to the Tiferet leadership for realizing that an artificially low-tuition model is not sustainable.
Obvious - How do you know HALB hasn't lowered its tuition and is not planning on lowering? Was there a letter sent out? is this what parents were told? Under your scenario why exactly is the AFFORDABLE Jewish Education group willing to invest in HALB if not because they dont think their model will make HALB more affordable?
It's called saving face.
Why does HALB want to help them save face? seems like a lot of intrusion into their school -they have a new administrator, have confirmed they are slowly turning over their lower school to a blended learning model. They are changing their school. They are not being paid to do nothing. An agreement was clearly reached outlining what expecations were. Your theory is dumb. It makes much more sense for HALB to have let Tiferet fail. Not to mention that Tiferet had a building, students, hired a principal. What sudden revelation came to AJE and the Board of Tiferet that they shouldnt open?
Halb's tuition schedule for this year can be found here: http://www.halbweb.org/web/tuitionschedule12-13.p...

It comes to about $13K per child plus $2,100 per family.

Tiferet was promising about $10K per child with no family obligations.

It will be interesting to see where they set the new tuition. My guess is that it will be closer to HALB's 2012-2013 tuition. They have the vast majority of the students & change to an existing school will happen very slowly.
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
Yeshiva Dad - your tuition #'s for HALB are misleading. For the grades Tiferet were offering, HALB is already very close. K at HALB is $10K, 1st-2nd is $10.7K; both not far off from Tiferet. You don't know what Tiferet would charge for middle school, for example.

HALB does have the $2,100 per family but $1,500 is a separate scholarship fee (should be tax-deductible) and if you have 2-3 kids it comes out to approx $700-$1000 per child). HALB is a huge school that probably has some fat. But with so many kids, there are definitely a lot of scholarships to give, so $1,500 per family does not sound unreasonable.
A little of topic, but what is the measure of success of these new schools?

that they keep tuition at x amount a year?
that they have x amount of school days?
that they enroll x amount of kids?

what are the academic and behaviorial measures of a successful model and education?
maybe - maybe Tiferet student's - those enrolled already - will stay at what they were slated to pay at Tiferet until HALB can lower its levels. Maybe the monetary effects wont be felt for a few years for the general HALB student body. My guess is that many of these issues were ironed out in the agreement that was made.
i keep getting emails and mailings from project ezrah asking me to give $ to help all the local families that cant afford food for pesach. if thats really true that there are so many local families who cant afford a couple hundred dollars I really think moriah holding tuition flat or yavneh reducing tuition is a joke. Even He Atid at 8k is definitely not a solution. If people really cant afford food the only solution i can see is that either teaneck becomes a town of only people who earn $300k plus or public school become an acceptable solution and a high quality talmud torah is formed to accompany it. I just dont see how 1/3 + of the community can continue to be on financial aid. The money is just going to dry up.
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
Yavneh reducing tuition is not a joke. What Yavneh has realized is that there are not merely 2 groups of parent's i.e., the rich and the scholarship families. Rather, there is a big chunk of us in the middle who are not on scholarship, but even a $100 increase will hurt and cause stress.
im sorry i send to yavneh and i dont know any one who appreciates the $100 decrease. Obviously an increase would be horrible but seriously $100? when tuition is 15k $100 is nothing. To make any difference they would have to reduce tuition 10%. who would go to a store if they advertised a 1% discount?
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
Did they decrease it again this year by $100? I have not seen anything yet? I will tell you I and a lot or people I know appreciate the $100 decrease. Yes, tuition is a fortune, but every year, I literally lose sleep this time of year because I am terrified of a tuition INCREASE. I literally do not have one extra penny so I do not know what I would do about an increase,
End Welfare's avatar

End Welfare · 627 weeks ago

Those of you with children of age for Heatidf who don't send there have no one to blame but yourselves. End of story. Now if your children are too old for Heatid then I honestly do feel bad for you.
any one who gets aid at a legacy but can afford he atid should seriously re think what they are doing. in my mind there is absolutely no excuse from taking charity when you can stand on your own feet.
Heatid is not the appropriate environment for every kid. They cannot meet the needs of everyone. I have friends with kids there....while it is fine for their kids ( for now) there are other kids that have behavior and attention issues that are not being met. The parents aren't going to pull the kids so they can be "forced" to pay higher prices or feel ridiculed by asking for assistance. who loses in the end?....these kids.

The community needs to stop hailing Heatid as the savior for all and also needs to stop bashing the other schools. Statements like the ones above are ridiculous and serve no good.
End Welfare's avatar

End Welfare · 627 weeks ago

"Heatid is not the appropriate environment for every kid. "

I couldn't agree more with that statement. I actually applaud Heatid for being honest and saying that their goal is to be able to reach the vast majority of kids but NOT ALL kids.
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
Agreed. When schools try to take on every academic challenge, that's when cost go up and up. Not every school should be designed to teach to every child's learning style. specialization in the schooling "business" will help improve efficiencies.
really, you agree with me - then why state things like this:

"Those of you with children of age for Heatidf who don't send there have no one to blame but yoursejavascript: postComment(0);lves. End of story. Now if your children are too old for Heatid then I honestly do feel bad for you."
Over the past 2 years, there has been a failure a year. First the west orange one never opened. Then, one in MD never opened. Now this LI program did not get off the ground. The "wave" of the future seems to be in BC ONLY.
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
your comment might be 'reality' if the programs in Baltimore and West Orange actually had anything to do with AJE and He'atid. The program in West Orange was a co-op school based on parents helping out with the school and had absolutely nothing to do with blended or differentiated learning
Pretty naïve to think that these new schools are 'standing on their own'. They are heavily subsidized by AJE. If you don't realize that, ask to see their budgets.
4 replies · active 627 weeks ago
Who knows how much they are subsidized, but the fact is since He'atid opened and WTA announced plans the schools in their respective communities have either reduced tuition or held it flat for the first time in recent memory. That along is a win.
schools were holding tuition flat for several years before heatid was even a thought.

the other school's can't really do the lower PK tuitions....Moriah raised tuition with the older grades and did massive layoffs.

When Yavneh cut pre-k tuition and lowered by $100, it came at the expense of larger class sizes and the elimination of many assistants.

Cutting tuition for PK only is a silly tactic anyway. Parents aren't fooled into choosing yavneh or noam over heatid based on a 1 year discount. seems like BPY is the only school to realize this...
Buster - that's right - all schools were holding tuition flat way before He'atid existed - some were even lowering tution significantly. Also - all schools were doing blended learning and differentiated learning as well - years before He'atid came into the picture Not to mention all schools were lowering the amount of random vacation and days off. All way before He'atid existed! If you actually think He'atid has had no impact on the educaitonal landscape of BC and Jewish schools throughout the country you are deceiving yourself - which is ok. If you think that educators and schools aren't paying attention to He'atid you are also decieving yourself. Call Rabbi Gralla and ask him how many principals and board memebrs from local schools as well as schools around the country have come to tour He'atid and are very interested in learning about what is going on there. The answer is many and this includes lower schools and high schools. The people on this blog can decieve themselves that He'atid is failing or is insignificant but the reality on the inside and those who are involved in education in BC and elsehwere is very different.
oh and btw - you can actually call Rabbi Gralla today because He'atid has school.
High School Dad's avatar

High School Dad · 627 weeks ago

I can't believe you guys are crying about elementry school. I have two kids in High School and my bill is over $50k!
1 reply · active 627 weeks ago
My oldest is in 4th Grade and I am already crying about how am I ever going to pay for High school.
Julie Wiener's avatar

Julie Wiener · 627 weeks ago

I'm doing an article about this for The Jewish Week, and would love to speak to Tiferet and HALB parents to find out how they feel about this. If any of you are on this blog -- or if any blog readers have friends at these places with whom they can put me in touch -- please e-mail me at julie.inthemix@gmail.com. Thanks! Julie Wiener, Associate Editor, The New York Jewish Week.
All the schools have been doing blended learning before heatid... It just wasn't a buzz word. All
Blended learning means is a combination of teaching mechanisms that includes some technology. Differentiated learning is def. happening in Noam and Bpy and has been at the core of their philosophies.

I'll give you the calendars have changed.

Lets not pretend that heatid is the greatest educational masterpiece. Just bc gralla is spending time showing his school to the whole world doesn't mean anything.
Give em a few years to see building expense, raises for staff and need for resource staff. They have kids with non-academic issues. "Differentiated" computer programs won't help these kids. Kicking them out kills the efficiency of the model.

Wish they would just be honest that the tuition is artificially set with heavy funding instead of fooling other start ups into believing it is really possible.

Moriah and Bpy had school today too.....
Buster clearly it means something to the educators. If not I would think the parent body made up of people like you should be pretty mad they are wasting their time.
Unfortunately your writing shows you know little about the school except what you have read feom blogs. Much of heatids differentiation does not take place using conputers. Stop being clueless and just repeating buzzwords and actually learn about the school
The recently converted to the blended learning bandwagon believe that they somehow own the concept. In reality there are a broad spectrum of approaches that fall under the banner of blended learning and all are valid and all are pretty much in experimentation mode. To say that the current schools haven't been doing blended learning is naive. Heatid has its own approach which includes lots of elements that other schools across the country are trying. The key fact is that there is no definitive proof that blended learning lowers tuition costs even a fraction of the amount that Heatid is claiming. Basically it is a no frills school with good marketing and very substantial financial backing. Time will tell how long it can run independently but to argue that they have cornered the marketing on new learning methods is silly.
most parents are just happy with the price. little to do with anything else. lets see what happens when they have more more 1st and 2nd graders. I heard report cards were a disaster, one of many issues.
1 reply · active 626 weeks ago
Many parents are actually happy at Heatid, their kids are learning, and the staff is pheonomenal. I don't know anyone in my child's kindergarten class not returning next year, and regardless of price- (since cheaper is NOT always better) I wouldn't screw with my child's education- there WERE issues with report cards, yes, but who cares? This is a new school and any person- parent, teacher etc.- who committed to it KNEW to expect some issues/challenges.
nfs - so you are saying that most of the parents who send there dont care about their children and their education but are happy to send their kids there because it is cheap? How pompous of you to think that you and legacy school parents are the only ones able to discern what a good education is and it must be at a more expensive school. Actually most parents are happy with the education. what is the 'disaster' you are talking about? that the school didn't do anecdotals? So the school realized its mistake and in the spring report cards there will be anecdotals. Yeah - a real disaster.
1 reply · active 626 weeks ago
EXACTLY!
Yes, many parents are happy to send there bc it is

A) cheap
B) good enough
C) they don't know any better since they were happy in daycare before

My friends with kids there were upset about the report cards. They didn't show that the teachers knew anything about the kids. They had contradictions amongst the check marks and really made them confused.

They are allowed to make mistakes, but again, lets not continue to say things are 100% roses and they are the best thing to happen educationally since the beginning of time.

Gralla's limitations having no educational experience with this age are beginning to show.
1 reply · active 626 weeks ago
...hmmm...my child's teacher knows her INSIDE and OUT-- we were in CONSTANT touch (and the teacher was in constant touch with all the parents by email/phone) because report cards are just a summary. Yes, comments/anecdotals would have been great- but nothing on a report card should be a surprise. You should, as a parent, be in touch/available to your teacher throughout the year. My daughter's teacher was incredible and has kept us in the loop and made herself available all year- since day one. And for the record- my child is an average to above average child, social, happy- no "special needs" (I'll give you that), but she's reading, davening with understanding and kavana, and is always asking/telling us about her morah.
My uncles kids are at halb And he didn't even know about this merger.
He can't see what halb has to gain by this.

Although halb has been loosing kids to ycq since it is cheaper... Maybe halb is looking to compete?
How could no "supervisor" or administrator notice problems with report cards before they are sent out? Didn't most of the teachers work at other schools prior to He'Atid. If so, shouldn't they at least know how to prepare report cards? Perhaps for blended learning, the consultants need to come in and give a seminar on that matter.

Obviously, joking around a bit, but if things as simple as this got messed up, there must be deeper issues. Painting it as perfection and utopia, but for the financial subsidy, is probably a bit much.
I doubt the lack of anecdotals was a mistake.
It is way easier for a teacher to fill out a checklist and have an administrator review than to write 25 anecdotals and proofread and spellcheck.
Parents in at least k and 1 have had experience with anecdotals elsewhere and decided the checklist wasn't acceptable.
RealityCheck's avatar

RealityCheck · 626 weeks ago

It's as simple as this: You get what you pay for.
If you want to skimp on education and spend your money on Pesach programs, that's your choice. Just quit fooling yourself that the education is any good.

Post a new comment

Comments by