Monday, August 13, 2012

Novel Concept: Fee for Services

Yavneh sent out an email (after the jump) stating that they are "thrilled" to inform about a fee for service program for speech/language therapy and occupational therapy for students who do not qualify for county sponsored programs.

This is a welcome change from the trend of the past few decades of everything moving to the communal pot, which is part of what caused tuitions to skyrocket.  Therapy for students that don't qualify for county subsidies are really somewhat of a luxury and should be paid for by the individual parents rather than burdening everyone else with them  Personally, I would make music & art a fee-for-service as well.

It would be nice to see the public schools move some extra-curricular activities to fee for service as well rather than having taxpayers pay for everything but that's a topic for another blog.





Yavneh Academy - ישיבת יבנה
Home | Homework | News | Photo
s | Calendar | More




We are thrilled to inform you that Yavneh Academy will continue to offer fee for service individual speech/language therapy services at school.  We will also continue to offer fee for service occupational therapy in our sensory gym in the Learning Center.  Bergen County small group speech sessions, as well as occupational therapy, will continue to service children who are eligible.  Fee for service is helpful for students who would benefit from either additional support or who do not meet the criteria for county support, but do need help in those areas.

Having school based therapy has been helpful for parents who cannot take their children to therapy after school.  It also allows students to have therapy during the day instead of after a long day of school and enables the therapist to work closely with each student’s classroom teacher.

Teaneck Speech and Language, an exemplary speech practice in Teaneck, will be at Yavneh two days a week to service students with various speech/language needs in school.  Many of our students have benefited from this fee for service program in the past.  If you are interested in having your child receive therapy during the school day in a fee for service program please contact Aviva Ramras at Teaneck Speech and Language - 201-862-0333 ext. 104.

The occupational therapist, Raquel Reichman, is a wonderful practitioner who has many years of training and experience in the field.  Occupational therapy in the fee for service program can be helpful for students who are not eligible to receive services through the district and need various fine motor, gross motor, and sensory strengthening. If you are interested in having your child receive therapy during the school day in a fee for service program, please contact Raquel Reichman at 201-240-5639.

As always, we remain committed to meeting our students’ individual needs and look forward to a wonderful and successful year for all our children.  If you have any questions, feel free to contact Dr. Sarah Feit at Sarah.Feit@yavnehacademy.org

Sincerely,
Dr. Sarah Feit
Director of Special Services
Rabbi Jonathan Knapp
Principal                                                  
 
SF/JK:es

Comments (20)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
not sure why you are applauding them. These kids weren't receiving these services for free as part of tuition. It is a just an added bonus that one of Yavneh's staff members will coordinate your child's speech & OT services in school so the parent doesn't need to shuttle them around after school.
You've obviously never had a disabled kid. Given today's school budgets, kids who are "borderline" have already had their services cut by the school districts. The public school kids who are still receiving services have disabilities which are on the severe side. Not sure what you want them to do to get an education.

Let's put it this way: healthy, smart little kids with a lisp are not getting public school speech services on your dime.

And the cost of a few speech sessions in district is negligible compared to $40,000-$100,000 intuition for kids sent to special schools outside the district. In a district like Teaneck that's probably a significant number of kids. No need to be quite so petty about a few sessions of speech and OT for kids who probably really need it.
Guest,

I'm applauding them for not taking Tesyaa's approach that every "healthy smart little kid with a lisp" is entitled to speech sessions on the community's dime. Seems like in the past every time a parent claimed they needed something for their kid it automatically became a public expense.
3 replies · active 659 weeks ago
Did I say that every kid who has mild needs should be entitled to public school services? I don't think so.
Then what are we arguing about?
Yavneh says they are "continuing" meaning this service is not new. Your tuition is paying for a Yavneh staff member to pay for this added value pay for service item.
Public schools have already taken your approach and cut services for mild needs. What more are you asking them to cut?
It's not that I want them to "cut" things but they should charge fees things that extra-curricular activities aren't really education. Sports teams would be an example.

I probably shoudn't have mentioned public schools because we risk getting way off topic.
1 reply · active 659 weeks ago
JS (hello)'s avatar

JS (hello) · 659 weeks ago

A lot of extracurricular activities are funded, in part, by those participating. Have you never seen the bake sales and car washes? Parents pay some fees as well.
Another Guest's avatar

Another Guest · 659 weeks ago

I think you're missing the ball here YD.

Those in yeshiva who meet the qualifications for receiving county services receive them from the county, in school, at no additional charges to the family. I happen to find it weird that the county-paid speech and occupational therapists in my child's school happen to be yeshiva parents, but that's another story. The services are paid with tax dollars. Like the guest said, these services are for those who don't qualify for county services or could use more beyond the services provided by the county.

Yavneh had already built a sensory gym for OT services (not sure at whose expense). This continued offering is an additional revenue stream for the school (not sure how much) and the therapist.It also makes the most of what was surely a costly investment.

While I agree with you that services for children who don't qualify for them from the county should be paid for by the parents (they usually are) and not the school community, I beg to differ with what you consider extra curricular.

Art, Gym & Music basics should be taught as part of the curriculum to develop a well rounded student. However, I believe that sports teams, bands, etc. are different and should be funded by the participants.
So where did I "miss the ball"?
Another Guest's avatar

Another Guest · 659 weeks ago

Realize the inaccuracy of my statement about you missing the ball. Sorry.

I will say thought that I still disagree with you regarding Art & Music. I believe these help develop a well rounded student and should be part of the curriculum.
NP. As far as Art & Music go, I think in the lower grades they can be done by the teachers. No reason K-3 classes need specialists for these subjects while teachers are already being paid to be there. I'm ok with once or twice a week having art & music specialists for the older grades.
For what it's worth, one of the local public high school has had a sign advertising a Car Wash Saturday 8-12 for the past few weeks. Usually it's the football team, cheerleaders, and other expensive (meaning travel expenses) programs doing that to raise money. I have no idea what their turn out is, or how similar things are in New Jersey, but I remember paying costs for most of my extra curricular activities.

If Yeshiva_Dad things that art/music during the school day needs to be phased out, we'll have to disagree, those these are short, inexpensive, and very good for kids. When I was in grade school we had about 30 minutes of various enrichment each day, generally, art, music, computer lab, PE, etc. and who knows what else. I presume that it was the teacher's break/lunch time, since they were policing us during lunch time, and the students in the school rotated through that classroom.
From personal experience -- my kids have very minor speech issues, but have been getting speech therapy for years.
Puzzled,

Was it done through your kids' school? Did you have to pay for it?
New Jersey special services are much more limited than New York City's services. They simply provide much less than NYC in this area. Also, New Jersey provides significantly less services to private school children than they do public school children. Meaning a NJ kid who would qualify for 2 hours a week of speech services if he were a public school student would likely qualify for significantly less services, or none at all, if he/she were a private school student.

In my experience the Yeshiva told us to provide services on our own dime (outside the school) to supplement the very limited services our children qualified for from the county. Not complaining about it, just saying what happened
teaneck parent's avatar

teaneck parent · 658 weeks ago

George, your statement about a child receiving more county funded service in public school than in private school sounds wrong (if not discriminatory and illegal). What are your sources for this? If it is legal for the private school student was to receive less, what's the point of county providing to private school students?
1 reply · active 658 weeks ago
Why do yeshivas who provide county services invariably direct the business to therapists who just happen to be yeshiva parents (as another commenter mentioned above)?
Education is one of the basic needs of human being. It is also essential for any kind of development. The purpose of education is to enlighten the individual and develop his/her capacity to the limit. It helps us distinguish between right and wrong. It enables us to make the right choices in life and to perform our duties properly. It ennobles our mind and refines our sensibility. In this way education can really remove the darkness of ignorance.

Post a new comment

Comments by