Thursday, March 15, 2012

Letter from He'atid on Scholarships

Dear Parents,

Yeshivat He’Atid is committed to opening its doors to all Jewish children regardless of the ability of their parent’s to pay full tuition. This has been made possible by a couple of very generous donors who have stepped forward to fully fund scholarship aid. As a reminder, Yeshivat He’Atid is NOT using tuition dollars to pay for financial aid.

Yeshivat He’Atid’s scholarship policy is in line with those of the community - we expect families to pay the maximum possible, viewing their financial obligations to the Yeshiva as a basic living expense, taking priority over any type of non-essential spending.

Please see the communal letter (BELOW) that was sent out last year for further information.

While we remain committed to helping those truly in need, we ask that families consider very carefully before applying whether or not they meet the appropriate criteria. By asking for financial aid, you are asking for charity and you should view it as such. If there are items in your family budget that you would not feel comfortable asking your neighbors to help subsidize, you should be cutting these first before applying for scholarship aid.

As has become the community standard, scholarship applications will be done entirely on-line at www.yeshivaaid.com. This will allow us to better compare families with similar circumstances (while acknowledging that no two situations are identical), keep better historical records, save on manual input time from our business office, and provide a common application that will be shared among schools with overlapping families.

Financial aid applications are due no later than April 10Th. All information will be kept in the strictest of confidence. The scholarship committee will be meeting right after Pesach to review applications and an in-person interview will in all likelihood be required before aid is awarded.

None of the above is meant to discourage families who are truly in need from applying. If after careful consideration of your family finances, you have honestly concluded that you can’t afford to pay tuition in full, please don’t hesitate to apply by the April 10Th deadline.

If after careful consideration of your family finances, you have honestly concluded that you can’t afford to pay tuition in full and you need help applying or have any questions, please send us an email to scholarship@yeshivatheatid.org .


Thank you,
Yeshivat He'Atid Tuition Committee

[Update: I posted the "Communal Letter" referred to above after the jump]



COMMUNAL LETTER
While we are fortunate to have an outstanding network of Jewish Day Schools and High Schools in northern New Jersey, we are very conscious of the affordability challenge of Jewish education. On this front, there has been a coordinated effort in our community under the auspices of Jewish Education For Generations (JEFG) to develop and execute innovative approaches to ease the tuition crisis. JEFG initiatives include generating broad communal funding for Day School scholarships (through NNJKIDS) improving school economics (in partnership with Yeshiva University/Avi Chai Foundation and UJANNJ) and recent work to create a Middle Income Affordability program. A separate group is actively exploring legislative channels to access public funding for our schools. All of these approaches will be necessary to positively impact affordability.

One of the hallmarks of our schools is their historical commitment to the principle that no child be denied a Jewish education based on financial circumstance. In light of the increasing pressure facing all the schools and their families, it is important to reiterate this commitment while at the same time clearly articulating our perspective regarding scholarships. Over the past several years, scholarship needs across our community have grown over 30% and now exceed $12 Million. All schools have worked extremely hard to raise funds and manage expenses so that a needs-blind policy can be sustained and scholarships awarded to all who qualify.

As fiduciaries of the entire parent body--both those families who can pay full tuition and those who cannot-- Scholarship Committees work to allocate an appropriate amount to those in need. We expect families to pay the maximum amount they can afford based on the principle that Yeshiva tuition is of the highest priority along with other basic living expenses. It is expected to take precedence over all discretionary expenses.

All the local day schools and high schools have worked together under the auspices of JEFG to adopt a single set of scholarship guidelines to ensure equity across our community. These have been widely in place and include discretionary spending choices such as home renovations, vacations, vehicles and spending on smachot; summer programs; financial decisions such as retirement savings and other investments; payment decisions such as applicants’ payment history with the Yeshiva and applicants’ willingness to sign promissory notes and liens in favor of the Yeshiva.

As in the past, scholarship allocation will be impacted by economic choices that prioritize these areas over tuition payment. This is the case regardless of who is paying the expense as we would expect that financial assistance provided by other family members should first contribute to a family’s basic living expenses such as tuition.

Each school will continue to review applications on a case-by-case basis with the sensitivity and understanding that no two family situations are the same. We will, however, be increasing our focus on, and review of, lifestyle, financial and payment decisions using the communal framework we have established to ensure consistency, equity and transparency across our community in this critical area.

Affordability of Jewish education is our community’s most urgent challenge. By working cooperatively on all fronts, we will meet the financial needs of both our families and schools as we continue to offer a quality Jewish education to all those who seek it.

Comments (21)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Finally a school with the guts to straight-up call scholarship for what it is: CHARITY! If the other schools had done this years ago then maybe we wouldn't have people abusing and gaming the system left and right like we do today.
1 reply · active 674 weeks ago
Thank you for reminding me that if I go out for pizza with my family I'm spending the "charity" that we received from our neighbors. (being in a restaurant is somehow perceived as a non essential abuse of budget albeit same cost as a dinner at home). Thank you for reminding me that although I didn't have a say I'm how much a school board decides to spend on the budget of installing iPads and smart boards I will get taxed with my tuition going up more than my cost of living adjustment increase. Thank you for reminding me that because I look normal I'm gaming the system by nit working because of a disability that isn't noticeable. Thank you for reminding me of what a friend ofone once said before I was disabled, "we don't need them to volunteer. If they are able to volunteer they should go back to work!".
the real guest's avatar

the real guest · 680 weeks ago

Not sure why Heatid needs a physical location at all. With the Khan method, can't they just have everyone learn by computer at home? Sounds like these "virtual seders". If you can't be there, just tune in on your computer! Maybe they can put Siri on the computers so they won't need any teacheers either.
1 reply · active 680 weeks ago
I am not from the area. Can you post the letter they refer to that has the criteria?
yeshivadad's avatar

yeshivadad · 680 weeks ago

Guest,

I just posted it above (after the jump)
-YD
Over 220 parents + children showed up at today's He'Atid event. Not too shabby for a school that hasn't even opened its doors yet.
what kind of event?
the voice's avatar

the voice · 680 weeks ago

I'm not sure they will actually open. Lots of logistical issues happening right now. My hunch is they will open regardless, but get ready for a great exodus from heatid in 2013. Even for 9k, parents want more than a bunch of robotic kids. You heard it here first!
The Voice,

We didn't hear it here first. Haters have been saying that since before this blog existed and before He'atid even had a name. If you have any actual information on "logistical issues" or anything else than please share it with us.
1 reply · active 680 weeks ago
My friend interviewed for a teaching position and was actually pretty excited to hear about the opportunity and the idea of something new and cutting edge. Her basic questions of " what on-line programs/curriculum will you be using so I can look at them?" and " what type of training will you be providing the staff on these programs to teach us how to effectively implement this new model? " were met with the answer of " We don't know yet". Needless to say, she left to consider her other options and to cross He'atid off her list.

I know the lovers will say they don't need to answer this now - but its practically April. These types of questions should have an answers. September is just around the corner and will be here faster than the blink of an eye.
all in good time's avatar

all in good time · 680 weeks ago

curious -

i asked a similar question yesterday to one of the members on the board. while the result is they currently do not have the answers, the view i got was not one of cynicism, but one of deep awe. they are taking the overall design of the program (from curricula objectives through vendor selection) very seriously and with great care. they are being led carefully by their consultant and sticking to a very manageable time line. it appears they are almost there, as they expect to be able to have such answers by mid-april.

they are starting a program from scratch, not merely tweaking prior year programs (which current schools have the luxury of doing), so it is something that takes time and diligence. the educational programming, and selection of teachers, are the most important pieces to the school's success, and there is no reason to shorten the time line for the sake of being able to say "it is done".

i do agree they should share it with the parent body at some point, as it would instill excitement and comfort in the school. to date, the school has been able to prove its competency, so i have no reason to doubt it will deliver on this as well.
1 reply · active 680 weeks ago
They are doing great facetime with their parents in assuring them of the progress and filtering the message, as they always have. However - perhaps that should have been their answer to my friend, and it wasn't. The answer she got was not as calculated almost as if she caught them off guard.
The message should be consistent.
There is no downside to trying out He'Atid for a year or two. If it turns out to not provide a great education then we send back to legacy school and pocket the tens of thousands saved to help pay for said legacy school. All you haters are just being foolish. I'm happy to be the guinea pig for all of you and so is my bank account! Having said all the above, I have met Rabbi Gralla and those laymen behind He'Atid and I fully expect it to provide an education that is at least as good as that of the legacy schools. I strongly suspect it will be even better.
Am I the only one that finds it funny that a school that is built on the concept of multiple approaches to learning including small groups teaching each other other and online learning is unable to communicate its approach with anything but a one-on-one discussion with its Principal or consultants. And even those interactions appear to leave people very confused. The only thing that He'Atid insists upon is that it can lower the cost of tuition. Everything else they are confused about. Is this part of the new teaching approach? Tell children to make up their end goal and only later figure out if you can do it?
have faith's avatar

have faith · 680 weeks ago

Funny,

I do not think there has been a demand by the parent body or the donors to publicly present its game plan. as such, it is not so strange that a school would not care to publicly present something as it merely opens itself up to outside criticism.

in terms of all the answers being wishy-washy, you may be correct, but as noted in some posts above, they have not fully developed its model. if you think there will not really be a model, then it will definitely be proven by september. until then, it is all hearsay - from the detractors and from the supports.
All our kids will end up in same high schools (TABC and Maayanot) and colleges (YU and Stern). The joke will be on all of you who paid hundreds of thousands of dollars more than you had to in order to get your kids to these high schools and colleges. Keep hating on He'Atid. Knock yourselves out. I'm laughing all the way to the bank.
the voice's avatar

the voice · 679 weeks ago

Dear Abe: (or is it Chump)? I can't believe you people are STILL shilling for heatid. Give it up already. No one else is going to register there for the coming year. If they can deliver, thats great, but I heavily doubt it. From the very beginning, you were dealing with people who had virtually no educational experience other than having gone to school. Would you send your kid to a doctor with no expereince because he cost less? How about a lawyer?. It never ceases to amaze how you people are dying to entrust your kids to this neophyte institution. I would NEVER send my kids to an unproven institution. If they provide a quality eduction over several years, I would consider it. Good luck with your kids, Abe . Please spare us the rah rah speech. Maybe we should buy you a cheerleader uniform.?
have faith's avatar

have faith · 679 weeks ago

voice -
it is perfectly understandable not to send your kid to a new institution. i certainly hope you actively voiced your opinions when BPY opened a handful of years ago, and when Noam opened up a decade ago. it is only fair that you hold your opinion constant, and not just pick on the new kid on the block.
DesckJockey's avatar

DesckJockey · 679 weeks ago

I think the letter is downright offensive and a shows haaza unbefore knownst.. I want to know if their posek approved that letter. Ever hear of the posuk in chumash "lo sashok" do not oppress- its ones of the 613. Not a chumra.
Education is undeniably one of the most important aspects of life. As we grow up, education can help us to develop as people, learning new life skills and improving our knowledge. All of this information is then carried across into our daily lives as an adult, helping us to become better, more informed citizens and enabling us to lead happier and more successful lives.

Post a new comment

Comments by